I went online to see what the TV critics had to say. I thought Time Magazine had the best review. The headline and subhead summed it up nicely:
Michael J. Fox Is Better Than "The Michael J. Fox Show."Critics not only watched the pilot with the rest of us; they received tapes of the show's next two installments. Time's critic was kinder than I was, saying that while not hilarious, the pilot "was very promising."
An extraordinary star returns in a very ordinary sitcom.
This doesn’t need to be a sitcom all about living with Parkinson’s per se; it’s a sitcom about a man re-changing his life. Is he the same guy after years home with his kids? Does he want to be? Does he still have what it takes at work? Will it be weird? That’s a fertile conflict; those are stakes. It’s something that can fuel story and character and, let’s hope, laughs.Unfortunately, he says, that idea just disappears in the next two episodes and what we're left with "is what worked least well in the pilot, a mundane, dated-feeling family comedy that feels like it's missing its laugh track."